Awww that was super cute! I absolutely loved the way Edward proposed. I also loved that he included Carlie in it. I wonder if she was aware that he was going to propse to Bella. Too cute, I can tell that things are getting tied up now, it's sad, but I can't wait to see what you have happen next.

Such a fantastic story!! Can't get enough of it!! Must admit that I have reread many of your chapters...just enjoying the love and the wonderful descriptiveness of your work! Had a feeling the yacht trip was a lot more than just a day cruise. So spectacular. So absolutely beautiful to see their world through your words. The way the bedroom is set with candles, the water, the sky, the cool air...all so beautiful to see through your text. Can't get enough. The poem....blew me away!! Had me smiling, with a few tears in my eyes. The perfect place to propose to both of his girls!! The ring sounds spectacular. Well, the rings actually!! Can't wait to see their engagement picture soon! I don't think it will be long before they are adding to their family, especially the way they go at it!! LOL!! Can't wait for more! Hope you had a great birthday!!! You deserve it!! This story alone should give you a place of honor!! xoxoxoxo

for some reason the second I started reading this chapter I knew Edward was going to propose lol but I didn't know he would propose to Carlie too! That was really cute.

First of all Happy Birthday! Loved seeing Bella stand up for her relationship. Take that Beverly! Hopefully we will get to see Edward and Bella marry and then have more children before the story ends?? Please!!!

Absolutely superb...

Hawtt

Happy Belated Birthday! I love how Aro got to be a vampire! Can't wait to see what Edward's surprise is 

HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!!!  I usually don't read all human storys...but I love this one.

I love it happy birthday to you!

Happy Birthday and thank you for a fabulous read, as always I await the next chapter with bated breathe. Hope u had an amazing birthday x

HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!!!!!!!!

great chapter as usual!  Happy Brithday  quicker updates always a bonus!!

I loved this chapter! It's so cute watching the family intereact with all those kids. Also Bella was kind of bad ass in this one. I'm glad they are working on everything together. That's a step in the right direction. Can't wait to see what you do next. Also, Happy Birthday! :)